Take the 2-minute tour ×
Writers Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for authors, editors, reviewers, professional writers, and aspiring writers. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've been - quite passionately - writing a lot of Pokémon fan-fiction. However, in contrast to Fan Fiction: a crutch or a good start?, I've been using it to build an entire world extending from canon. While I have been keeping to canon as much as possible, my stories take place in my own Region, and I fill in a lot of holes - for instance, I've polished up the story of why Arceus created other Legendaries (basically self-preservation because his body was not strong enough for his power), and expanded on the roles of the Legendaries (most notably, Giratina rules over the Afterlife in my stories).

If I may give an example of my work, Injustice is a short story I wrote a while ago.

My stories almost always revolve around the perspective of the Pokémon. I feel there's a whole unexplored world there (and the Mystery Dungeon games barely scratch the surface of it).

My main question, however, is this: My work tends to be much more... well, I don't think it's for as young children as Pokémon is in general. My stories tend to feature very harsh situations (I'm currently working on a series where the antagonist is cruel, manipulative, and ruthless in his pursuit of the main characters, ultimately killing them quite horrifically - but, thanks to Giratina, Death is Cheap given the right circumstances!) I've even written an erotic fan-fiction (don't judge me!)... the point is, the "target audience" is really "other people who have grown up with Pokémon for a long time", rather than younger, newer fans.

Is this a problem? Am I doing something wrong by writing these stories?

Additionally, if I decide to publish my stories elsewhere than online (ie. physical copies)... is that even allowed? Considering the "giant boobs" in certain Pokémon Manga, I get the feeling there's some leeway there, but... I'm just hesitant to put so much work into something only to have it shut down for some reason XD

I don't know... I guess I'm just hoping for some general guidance on the do's and don'ts of fan-fiction...

share|improve this question
    
Niet, you may find these questions and their answers helpful: (and possibly not): Fan Fiction: a crutch or a good start?, How to continue someone else's story gracefully, with fan-fiction?. –  Neil Fein Apr 14 at 15:57
    
Hi @NeilFein, thanks for commenting! I actually linked the first one in my question :p As for the second one, it seems more related to using specific known, established characters whereas my work is more about the universe itself with otherwise unknown individuals... Hmm... –  Niet the Dark Absol Apr 14 at 16:14
    
I don't think it will work well with Pokémon specifically, but EL James's Fifty Shades of Grey started out as Twilight fanfic. She changed some names and details and got large book contracts. –  Lauren Ipsum Apr 14 at 17:15
2  
"Are they allowed" in what sense? Are you asking an ethical question (is it right and proper that I do this)? That isn't usually a good fit for Stack Exchange as it's primarily opinion-based. Could you focus this more on your publication goal? A question asking how far you can deviate from the norms of the fandom and still get your stores accepted for publication would probably work better. Thanks. –  Monica Cellio Apr 14 at 17:25

1 Answer 1

up vote 2 down vote accepted

You're a pokefarm user too, yay! Uh... anyway...

Is this a problem? Am I doing something wrong by writing these stories?

I assume you're asking this in a legal sense, and it's not a problem if you're not making profit from it. Make sure you've got disclaimers and all that good stuff. If' you're not asking in a legal sense, then: You can write whatever you want and post it (pretty much) anywhere, although obviously some places will just boot you for posting your story on their websites. But writing fanfiction isn't really a problem in this sense either.

Additionally, if I decide to publish my stories elsewhere than online (ie. physical copies)... is that even allowed?

Tch, publishing... I'm not particularly knowledgeable on Pokemon, but some authors expressed that you can't write fictions in their universes, some authors would prefer if you didn't profit from their material, and so on. Also, some places are strict about copyright infringement and so on. In Japan, publishers couldn't give less of a crap about people publishing works from their copyrighted material, though. That's why doujinshis are rampant over there. Rampant. In Japan, publishers think of doujinshis as pretty much "free press coverage" so... they don't care. In America (which is where I am, I don't really have a frame of reference for outside of America, sorry), that's grounds to get you sued. What you see in manga is, very likely, a result of better selling doujinshi (or just doujinshi artists being asked to make official material), but... the culture in Japan and the cultures outside of Japan towards copyright is way, way too different for me to tell you it's cool for you to publish your work in America (or elsewhere) without seeking permission first. When you ask about publishing a fan work (physically) on fanfiction websites, you normally get rerouted to answers like this. You can distribute your work not-for-profit here in America electronically, but I'm not sure about publishing a hard copy and distributing that. It's okay if it's copies for you and your friends, but you seem to want to publish and sell, like a business? In which case, no, not in America, you can't do that.

That being said... You're allowed to sell physical copies of your fan work at conventions. You still need to know the stance of the copyright holder (and there are more licensing issues if you're outside of Japan), because they can absolutely still sue you into next week. But conventions normally set limits as to how much you can sell (for example, only 300 copies of your self-published comic or something like that, though the pricing is also kind of important) and they also tend to have "permission" from licensing companies, who send lawyers to check out the works being sold. If your work does have mature themes, you will probably have to notify convention staff. They'll put you in an artist alley section (if they have it) for mature audiences. That way, younger people can't buy your material.

Doesn't mean you can go crazy (you should check the limitations to your publishing rights) but you absolutely can sell your fan work at an Artist Alley of your choice. Just know you're not going to be making billions off your work (or thousands. You'd be lucky to pull like $300 with one work alone, depending on your convention). Lawyers patrol the Artist Alleys, so you can get called out if they think you're overstepping your boundaries. You sound like you're a writer, someone who isn't producing a comic or artwork, I mean. I think they might read your stuff at the convention or at least page through it? Definitely talk with the convention staff if you want to know what to expect from the lawyers at conventions. Also, talk to people on websites outside of Pokefarm. DeviantArt is probably your best bet for finding out about Pokemon licensing initially (there are a lot of people who do this sort of stuff on DeviantArt, so it's a good place to ask about where to look for information, who to ask for information, what things are okay, and what things aren't okay) but if you want to be safe, branch out from there. It's a legal issue if this is the route you're pursuing, so I can't help and I don't know how much Writers SE can help.

But like I said you can still absolutely be sued. But you'll get a Cease and Desist notice first, most likely. Parodies normally get off with a little more lee-way, fan-art and fan-work is subjective. Again, this gets into legal issues I don't know much about, so...

In general, you need to really ask around about your particular fandom before publishing works for profit from that fandom willy-nilly. If you want to sell your work, you have to do it at the right places-- a comic book store can't sell your work next to licensed material, a bookstore won't take your fan novel, etc. etc. Long story short, do your homework!

share|improve this answer
    
"You're a pokefarm user too" - hehe, I made PokéFarm ;) –  Niet the Dark Absol Apr 14 at 16:43
    
xD I'd have known if I'd checked your profile page! I couldn't see Injustice (I'm at work so I can't see anything but the address and a "what are you even doing on this website" message), but I'm always pretty stoked when I meet anyone else playing Pokefarm, even if I can't play much anymore. Good luck with publishing, if that's where you're headed next! –  Ice-9 Apr 14 at 16:53
    
Me too - it's always exciting when I meet a player at conventions and stuff! Anyways, the main reason PF/PFQ exists is because of Japan being so different with regard to copyright - I've given business cards to Mr. Masuda and Mr. Morimoto practically saying "look at us, we exist!" and that was years ago XD So yeah. Thanks for the answer! –  Niet the Dark Absol Apr 14 at 16:59
1  
This looks like a good answer, but I'd be very careful taking legal advice from a stackexchange site... –  evilsoup Apr 14 at 19:18
    
@evilsoup I didn't give any legal advice. Actually, multiple times I say that I can't give any advice because I don't understand legal issues. What part of this answer seems like it's "legal advice" to you? I'd like to fix it so that the answer isn't confusing. –  Ice-9 Apr 14 at 19:48

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.